Acid Wash Vs Resurfacing Pool: Comparing the two popular pool maintenance options

Acid wash is a surface-level cleaning method, while pool resurfacing involves more extensive renovations and repairs. Swimming pools require regular maintenance, including cleaning and repairs.

At some point, you may consider refreshing the pool’s surfaces. Two common options for this are acid washing and pool resurfacing. Acid washing is a less invasive, surface-level cleaning technique that removes stains and discoloration from the pool‘s walls and floors. On the other hand, pool resurfacing involves more extensive renovations that can include removing and replacing old pool finishes. This can improve the pool’s appearance, structural integrity, and longevity. Ultimately, the best option for you will depend on the condition of your pool, your budget, and your preferences. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between acid washing and pool resurfacing to help you make an informed decision.

Acid Wash Vs Resurfacing Pool: Comparing the two popular pool maintenance options



Maintaining a pool is crucial for its longevity and aesthetic value. Acid washing is a process that removes a layer of surface stains caused by chemicals and algae buildup. However, it can also damage the pool surface and is not recommended for frequent use.

Resurfacing is a more permanent solution that involves replacing the entire pool surface. It is a costly process but can give a completely new look to the pool. Choosing the right pool maintenance option depends on various factors such as the age and condition of the pool, budget, and personal preferences.

It’s important to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each option before making a decision. A well-maintained pool not only adds value to your home but also provides a relaxing and refreshing space for you and your loved ones to enjoy.

Understanding Acid Wash And Resurfacing

Acid wash and resurfacing are two common methods for pool maintenance. Acid wash is a process that involves cleaning and removing the top layer of the pool surface. The acid is typically a mix of water and muriatic acid. This method can be effective in removing stains, scaling, and buildup on the surface of the pool.

On the other hand, resurfacing is a more involved process that involves completely removing the existing surface of the pool and replacing it with a new one. This is a more long-term solution that can improve the overall appearance and efficiency of the pool.

It is important to consider the condition of your pool and budget before deciding which method to choose. An experienced pool contractor can provide valuable recommendations and advice.

How to Acid Wash a Swimming Pool 4K ~ Which Acid to Buy ~ Retail VS Professional Grade Acid

Pros And Cons Of Acid Wash

Acid wash and resurfacing are two methods used for pool maintenance. Acid wash is an economical option for pool owners, as it removes discoloration and stains caused by algae and other debris. Acid wash, however, can damage the surface of the pool and lead to future issues.

Also, acid wash can’t repair cracks or rough spots unlike resurfacing. Conversely, resurfacing provides a complete makeover to the pool, it is expensive though. The downside is that resurfacing is a longer process and requires heavy equipment. Its durability makes it valuable for long-term pool maintenance.

Ultimately, pool owners must decide whether to choose acid wash for a quick fix or invest in resurfacing for long-term benefits.

Pros And Cons Of Resurfacing

Resurfacing is a popular method for pool maintenance. The advantages of resurfacing include a safer pool surface that is more comfortable on the feet. It also enables easier cleaning and enhance the aesthetics of the pool. On the downside, it is expensive and could require a longer time frame for installation.

In addition, surface defects such as visible cracks, may still show up during resurfacing. Overall, resurfacing provides a cost-effective method for pool maintenance.

Factors To Consider When Choosing Between Acid Wash And Resurfacing

Acid wash and resurfacing are two ways to improve the appearance and longevity of your pool. The age and condition of the pool are important factors to consider, as resurfacing may be necessary for older pools with substantial damage. Budget and time frame are important considerations as well, as acid wash can be a less expensive and quicker solution.

Aesthetics also play a role in the decision, as resurfacing allows for more design options. Ultimately, the choice between acid wash and resurfacing depends on the individual needs and goals for the pool. Consultation with a professional is recommended to determine the best course of action.


After looking at the pros and cons of acid wash and pool resurfacing, there are a few factors to keep in mind. Acid wash is cheaper, but resurfacing has a longer lifespan. Acid wash can harm the environment, while resurfacing helps conserve water.

If you have an older pool, resurfacing may be the best option. However, if you’re looking for a temporary fix, acid wash may work for you. Ultimately, our final recommendation is to weigh the lifetime value and environmental impact before making your decision.

Choose the option that meets your budget, your pool needs, and your environmental values.

Frequently Asked Questions Of Acid Wash Vs Resurfacing Pool

Q1. What Is Acid Washing, And When Should I Consider It For My Pool?

### a1. Acid washing is a process that involves the use of acid to remove the top layer of a pool’s plaster, which can help remove stains and discoloration. It should be considered if your pool has stubborn stains that cannot be removed by normal cleaning methods.

Q2. What Is Pool Resurfacing, And Why Is It Important?

### a2. Pool resurfacing refers to the process of replacing the top layer of a pool’s plaster, which can help to restore its appearance and extend its lifespan. It’s important because over time, pool plaster can become worn, stained, or damaged, which can affect the pool’s overall safety and hygiene.

Q3. Which Is Better: Acid Washing Or Pool Resurfacing?

### a3. The answer depends on the condition of your pool. If your pool has only minor stains or discoloration, acid washing may be sufficient. However, if the pool is showing signs of wear and tear or has significant damage, pool resurfacing is the better option.

Q4. How Long Does It Take To Acid Wash A Pool?

### a4. The process of acid washing a pool typically takes between 8 and 12 hours to complete, depending on the size of the pool and the extent of its stains.


To sum up, choosing between acid wash and pool resurfacing depends on various factors. Acid washing is an affordable option for removing stains from the pool’s surface, while resurfacing is a more thorough method that can withstand wear and tear.

Resurfacing options, such as pebble tec, aggregate, and fiberglass, are long-lasting and require less maintenance than acid washing. However, acid washing can improve the appearance of the pool’s surface and extend its lifespan, by removing dirt and algae buildup. Regardless of which option a pool owner chooses, maintaining proper pool chemistry and regular cleaning are essential for keeping the pool looking good and functioning well.

So, it is always better to consult with a pool professional to determine the ideal option according to the pool’s condition and budget.

Home Advisor Blog

Home Advisor Blog is a reader-supported blog. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.